Why You Are Likely Underinsured And Could Lose Thousands With Renters Insurance

What the Landlord covers
When you rent a property, the landlord will normally be responsible for insuring the building and anything fixed or fitted to the property. They are not always legally obliged to do this, but most mortgagors will require it and sensible homeowners will want to cover the cost of damage to their property.
What you need to cover
If they have provided contents for the property as well, such as furniture and carpets, they may cover this by their own contents insurance too. You however, will be responsible for insuring anything that you have brought to the property with you, from furniture to jewelry. The coverage for loss of personal property may be either on a full replacement value basis, where the full cost of replacement is covered, or for a lower price depreciation is taken into account.
Policy details
As well as personal property, your insurance policy may cover loss of use of the premises, if you have to move out because of fire for example. It should also cover your personal liability for injury to anyone using the premises. You need to read the policy carefully, as what is excluded can be as important as what is not. You may also want to consider add-on insurance for damage caused by hurricanes, or flooding for example, which isn’t included in many policies.
The lease may require it
Many leases will also now require the tenant to take out renter’s insurance, so that if the tenant damages the property, the landlord or other tenants can claim against this it.
Risk of underinsuring
One of the mistakes that people often make is underestimating the value of cover that they need. When you actually sit down and add up the value of everything you have in the property, you may be in for a surprise. If you do substantially underestimate your cover, the insurers may well punish you by reducing any pay out commensurately. So if you are say 30% underinsured, they may only pay out 70% of the value of any one item on a replacement basis. You may also need to insure particularly valuable items separately.
Affordable
A basic renter’s insurance policy can be very affordable, less than $1 per day in some cases. Several providers offer free online quotes, so you can easily compare prices and levels of coverage.
Related Sales Tips

The Hidden Condo Insurance Mistake That Could Cost You Thousands
You may think that you if own a condo, as your Association has insurance, you don’t need any. Their insurance won’t however, cover the things that could most affect you. The condo association insurance will likely only c...
Nov 2, 2026

Why Most Homeowners Are Secretly Responsible For Their Sewer Pipe Repair Costs
Sewer pipes are not the kind of thing you’re likely to think about very often, but when there’s a problem you need a solution fast. Sewer pipes are always being used so they can get blocked at any time. Many people make ...
Oct 11, 2026

Why Most Homeowners Are Ignoring The Massive Risk Of Earthquakes
You hope it will never happen to you – but one day it could. That’s the point of insurance - to cover risks that may be unlikely, but could leave you seriously out of pocket if they do. Why you need it There’s nothing mo...
Oct 10, 2026

About the Author
Emily Williamson
Emily Williamson is a personal finance expert dedicated to helping readers find genuine savings and smart shopping strategies. With years of experience in consumer finance, Emily combines practical advice with trusted insights to guide you toward smarter financial decisions.